Is humility a virtue in athletics?

The Winter Olympics in Vancouver have brought us many thrilling events, but none more exciting than the accomplishments of Apolo Anton Ohno. Ohno has become the most decorated US Winter Olympian in history. In order to win the bronze medal Saturday night in the short track 1,000-meter final, Ohno had to come from last place on the final lap of the race. He knew the gold and silver were out of the question based on his positioning. Ohno said, “I really had to fight. I can’t wait to watch the tape and see how I came back from last place to win bronze.”

However successful Ohno may be he wasn’t quick to brand himself as the most decorated American in Winter Games history. “In my mind, that’s a hard question. How do you answer that? I don’t put labels on myself,” he said. “I consider myself an athlete on my third Olympic Games, working my heart out. My goal was to come out and put my heart and soul into the Olympic Games and I’ve done that.” More impressive than the accomplishments of the athlete is his modesty towards those accomplishments. Many athletes train in order to win the gold, but Ohno races for the love of the sport and because of that love he has been able to become the most decorated US Winter Olympian in history.

Phillip Tuttle
Social Foundations of Coaching
ND 2010

Olympic Hockey: A Dangerous Diversion?

Now, I do not claim to be anyone remotely resembling an expert in the field of hockey, the NHL, or the Olympics, but I really wanted to bring something up for discussion. Perhaps, it may be that I am biased towards my team (the Chicago Blackhawks) because they are leading their division, are second in their conference, and are third in the league (and I hope that I do not jinx them for bragging like this); and that I miss watching Patrick Kane and Jonathan Toews play side-by-side instead of head-to-head, but I believe that having Men’s Hockey as an Olympic event is unhealthy for team dynamics in the NHL.
Many players jump at the chance to play in the Olympics to honor their country and at the chance to play with enemies and against teammates. Yes, the Olympics are fun and exciting to watch. They certainly give people like me the chance to shamelessly cheer for players that I despise (but respect) during the regular NHL season, like Joe Pavelski of the San Jose Sharks, because they are now playing for a team that I can get behind, Team USA. At the same time, however, there are players from my Blackhawks that are not playing for USA. How can I cheer for Jonathan Toews, who is by far my favorite Hawk and a member of Team Canada, during the USA-Canada game? It is really not as difficult as I may make it seem. I am cheering for Team USA regardless, but feel like I am being disloyal to the other Hawks players who are a part of other countries’ Olympic teams. As a fan, the Olympics are nothing short of frustrating.
All self-pity and tangents aside, I disapprove of Olympic Men’s Hockey mainly because of its timing. At this time of year, NHL teams have more or less played in over three-quarters of their regular season games, having had 4.5 months to create a solid team. With a month and a half left in the regular season after the Olympics are over, will this two week vacation have an effect on team unity? Certainly each NHL team has its own dynamic and unique relationships between players and coaches, as does each Olympic team. In order for a team to do well in the Olympics, players have to adapt and to basically let go of any quirk or loyalty that was present within their NHL team. What worries me, and many other critics of having Men’s Hockey as an Olympic sport, is the amount of time that it will take for NHL teams to return to normal and to restore the relationships and habits that had made their team strong before. Will teams that were “hot” going into the Olympic break still have that fire come March when the NHL season starts up again? Though problems may only be temporary and a team might be able to bounce back within a week or so, having the Olympics so late in the season makes the pressure to return to normalcy that much greater. Slip-ups near the end of the season can have huge implications in regards to play-off bids and final standings, so why place oneself and ones team in such a situation by competing in the Olympics?
Besides having a potential to harm team dynamics, the fact that international hockey and NHL rules are different can have impacts on players’ styles and performance during the shifts. Probably having the most risk is the difference between what is being called for obstruction in NHL and international games. International games have been more lenient regarding what is being called for penalties than NHL games, especially since the NHL cracked down on the rules after its one year hiatus a couple years back. After two weeks of being able to play harder, and maybe more recklessly, considering retaliation is more difficult since a fight in an international game will get a player kicked out, I can imagine that it may be difficult to get back into the swing of things upon return to the NHL. Perhaps, I am being a bit melodramatic on this point, but it is really hard for me to discount the power that one game can have on a player and even on a team. Stupid penalties can make or break a game and a single game can be all that it takes to keep a team from advancing.
So although I will support Team USA in the Olympics and did cheer for them during their 5-3 victory Sunday over Canada, I truly hope that there will be no Team USA, or Canada, or Slovakia taking the ice in Sochi in 2014, for my sanity, as well as for the well-being and cohesiveness of all NHL teams, so that they may have their best shot at the Cup.
Kelly Marszalek
ND 2010
Social Foundations of Coaching