Reggie Bush's Heisman Scandal

The Heisman Trophy is one of sport’s most prestigious awards, given yearly to the best college football player in the country. For an amateur athlete, there is no greater glory or honor. This week, for the first time in its long and storied history, the Heisman trophy was returned. Reggie Bush, the 2005 winner, gave back the trophy after an NCAA investigation into his college playing days was announced.
During his time at USC, Reggie Bush put up staggering numbers and drove his team to one of the longest winning streaks in NCAA history, winning two national championships. It could easily be argued that he was one of the greatest players in college football history. He seemed to be a good guy who was genuinely likable, even if he was dominating your favorite football team. Unfortunately, it turns out he may have been breaking all sorts of rules.
The NCAA has alleged that Reggie Bush took payments and housing during his time at USC, something clearly not allowed for an amateur athlete. These violations by Bush have not only hurt his legacy, but his actions have also decimated the USC football program and athletic department. The school will likely have to forfeit its national championships and has already removed all signs of Bush’s time at the school. They gave back their copy of Bush’s Heisman a month ago. USC has done all it can to apologize for this situation and correct its wrongs. Unfortunately, Bush has not.
Once the NCAA had made it clear that Bush and the school had committed violations, USC immediately began to rid itself of the stain and embarrassment of the violations. Reggie Bush could have followed suit and began to reestablish himself as a role model for young athletes. Instead, he has constantly denied any wrongdoing in the face of insurmountable evidence. When he finally gave back his Heisman trophy at the beginning of the week, it seemed like a humble gesture. Perhaps Bush was finally admitting his wrongs and showing remorse. Instead, the next day Bush held a press conference to announce that the return of the trophy was “in no way an admission of guilt.” Rather, Bush said he simply wanted to stop being investigated by different groups. What appeared to be an act of honest humility turned out to be a selfish decision.
Reggie Bush is yet another example of why athletes cannot be looked to as role models. He had the chance to be a great, honest, and inspiring football player for America’s young athletes. Instead, he took money in college. When he had a chance to show the world how to fess up to your mistakes, he took the easy way out and denied wrongdoing. Reggie Bush, an NFL superstar, is looked up to by kids across America. And it’s a shame.
Mike Hill, ND 2012
Social Foundations of Coaching